
Editor’s note: The following is a letter to the editor. The opinions expressed in this letter are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect those of The Mendocino Voice. If you would like to submit a letter to the editor feel free to write to [email protected].Â
Dear Editor:
Recent commentary by Mary Rose Kaczorowski regarding train horns and the possibility of a Quiet Zone in Fort Bragg highlights a recurring problem in this debate: people continue arguing against positions nobody is actually taking.
Ms. Kaczorowski asks whether the City of Fort Bragg should evaluate the feasibility of a Quiet Zone. The answer is yes. Mendocino Railway has said exactly that for years. In fact, more than five years ago, we suggested exploring the Quiet Zone process and the crossing improvements that would be necessary to support one.
Federal law provides a process for establishing Quiet Zones, and the railroad has never opposed exploring that process. What is often overlooked is that a Quiet Zone requires engineering analysis, safety improvements, regulatory review, funding and cooperation between the requesting agency and the railroad.
In other words, it takes two.
That history matters because it directly contradicts the narrative that the railroad is somehow standing in the way of progress. We are not. We never have been.

Unfortunately, much of the public discussion has been driven by speculation rather than facts. Claims that the railroad installed a “mega horn” to make trains louder are false. Likewise, discussions about railroad operations should be grounded in law, engineering and safety requirements, not assumptions or rumor.
The railroad has consistently expressed a willingness to participate in Quiet Zone planning and evaluate potential solutions. What we requested in return was simple: that the City acknowledge in writing the legal limits that already exist under federal law and the City’s own jurisdictional authority.
The City declined.
That decision is disappointing because it demonstrates a continuing disconnect between the City’s stated commitment to collaboration and its actions. Meaningful progress requires both parties to acknowledge legal realities, respect the limits of their authority and work together toward a common objective.
Ms. Kaczorowski is certainly entitled to her opinions. What none of us are entitled to do is substitute opinion for fact. Discussions about railroad safety, federal regulation and Quiet Zones should be grounded in expertise, evidence and law, not assumptions about how railroads operate.
Mendocino Railway will continue to comply with all applicable laws and regulations, as it always has. We remain willing to engage in good-faith discussions regarding crossing improvements and a potential Quiet Zone. We are also prepared to make our correspondence with the City public so residents can review the record for themselves.
At the end of the day, our position remains straightforward: We will continue to follow the law. We ask no more and no less of the City.
Robert Jason Pinoli
President & CEO
Mendocino Railway / California Western Railroad (Skunk Train)
Fort Bragg
