Students Itzel Vargas (left) and Lesly Argueta store their cellphones in “Phone Parking” pouches in Diego Garcia’s classroom at Richmond High School in the West Contra Costa Unified School District. (Louis Freedberg via EdSource)

RICHMOND, CA., 11/21/26 — One hour and 52 minutes. 

That is the duration of Diego Garcia’s media and graphic arts class at Richmond High — and the length of time students are expected to leave their cellphones in plastic pouches at the front of the classroom. 

To many teenagers (and adults), that might seem like an excruciatingly long time to be separated from texting, TikTok, Instagram and the other apps that make phones a constant distraction machine.   

But Garcia’s students dutifully put their phones in the pouches with little fuss. 

When the 51-year-old Garcia first introduced his no-cellphone rule after the pandemic, students would sometimes leave his classroom rather than give up their phones. 

To get the message across, Garcia designed a large round sticker reading “no cellphones in Mr. Garcia’s class.” The message is repeated in a large colorful poster on the front door and another hanging from the blackboard.

These days, most students have no problem putting their phones in pouches, he says.  

Garcia’s experience illustrates one of the challenges schools are facing as California’s new cellphone restrictions took effect this year: The state has required schools to limit students’ phone use, but how those rules are enforced can vary from school to school and classroom to classroom. 

At Richmond High, Garcia says, consistency, communication with parents and engaging students in class have helped him win what he calls “the cellphone wars.” With about 1,200 students, Richmond High is one of six high schools in West Contra Costa Unified School District in the San Francisco Bay Area.

“As with any kind of addiction, if you try to stop students (from using their phones), it can backfire,” Garcia says. “But if you can get them to concentrate and substitute that addiction for something fun and attractive, then they can cope with it better. Otherwise, you’ll lose them real quick.”

Diego Garcia, a teacher at Richmond High School in West Contra Costa Unified, has figured out how to keep students off their cellphones during class time. (Louis Freedberg/EdSource)

Teachers get to decide how to enforce policy

Last academic year, West Contra Costa Unified School District, with 29,000 students, introduced its own cellphone policy banning cellphones in classrooms, modeled closely on the state law approved in 2024.  

The district leaves it up to teachers to decide how or where students should store them during instruction time. Pouches are common, as is having students stash them in their backpacks. 

Students point out that it is not unusual for some of their classmates to place decoys in the pouches to fool teachers — like disposable “burner” phones, old nonworking phones, or even paper phone cut-outs.  

In August, the district surveyed schools about their cellphone policies to see how its cellphone ban worked last year. Only 34 of the district’s 56 schools responded. Of those, 19 reported “consistent implementation of the policy.”  In its report to the school board, district officials did not describe what information the other 15 schools provided. 

School district Superintendent Cheryl Cotton said the survey results did not mean that schools were not enforcing the policy.

“I feel confident that I don’t have any schools that are not looking at this issue and not addressing this issue with our students,” she said.  “This is not about punishing students. It’s about shifting our culture.”

Based on EdSource interviews with students at several district schools, it is clear that there are wide variations in how the cellphone policy is enforced. Complicating the landscape, there are several variations of the policy on the district’s website. 

‘He’s the only teacher I listen to about the phones’

Garcia, the Richmond High teacher, sees himself as a veteran of the “cellphone wars.” He began implementing restrictions on their use long before state and district mandates. He is clear that cellphones have no place in his classroom.

Initially, some of the pushback he experienced came from parents anxious about not being able to reach their students during emergencies. Garcia met with parents to explain that “we weren’t dealing with bad kids, just a bad habit,” and stressed the urgency of helping kids overcome what he describes as “IAD,” or internet addiction disorder.

He got help from Rocio Reyes, the school’s principal, who met with parents to explain how they could reach their students in an emergency. “We’re not coming in and saying, no cellphones and kids can never communicate with families,” she said. 

Garcia recognizes that his graphic design class is inherently more fun than most academic courses. And, he draws on his past experience as a youth counselor and focuses on setting clear, consistent expectations. If he sees a phone decoy, which is rare, he sits down with the student to remind them of what the policy is, and the reason it is being imposed. 

Students say that Garcia’s approach is not typical of all teachers.  

“Honestly, he’s the only teacher I listen to about the phones,” said 17-year-old Lesly Argueta, a 12th grader.  “In other classes you can say ‘no’ and they won’t do anything about it.”

Her classmate, Itzel Vargas, also 17, said teachers use different methods. Some have pouches, others tell students to keep them in their backpacks. Some don’t insist on confiscating the phones, which then can affect the whole classroom. 

“Some students don’t listen, and they’re still on it, and they get distracted and then other students around them get distracted,” said Vargas, who is in 12th grade.  

Students also say that staying off their phones is easier when they are engaged in class. 

“Sometimes when I’m finished with my work or if there’s nothing really to do, then it does get a little boring,” said Vargas. Then she is tempted to try to get back on her phone.

Garcia says he has never sent a student to the principal’s office for disciplinary action. 

“If I were to do that, then I’d be taking all of my power to connect with the kids, and giving that authority to someone else,” he said.

This article first appeared in EdSource here.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *