A person stands in a vineyard, touching grapevines with autumn-colored leaves under a clear blue sky.
Jake Fetzer, co-owner and winemaker at Masút Vineyard and Winery, stands in one of the winery's vineyard blocks in the Eagle Peak Mendocino County appellation near Redwood Valley, Calif., on Wednesday, Oct. 14, 2026. Masút is the only winery in the 26,260-acre appellation, which Fetzer and his brother, Ben, spent about a decade getting the federal government to establish. (Roger Coryell/Bay City News)

MENDOCINO CO., 10/28/26 — Jake Fetzer was giving a tour of his family’s vineyards on an October Wednesday, when he pointed up the canyon at the mountain above them.

“This is Eagle Peak right here, the mountain,” he said. “That’s what it’s named after.”

The mountain gave its name to the Eagle Peak Mendocino County American Viticultural Area, a federally drawn grape-growing region whose name can go on wine labels. It covers about 26,260 acres of steep hillside west of Redwood Valley, between Ukiah and Willits, reaching east to U.S. Highway 101 at Reeves Canyon Road. Fetzer and his brother Ben spent about a decade getting the federal government to draw it. Along the way, Jake Fetzer had to defend its name against Fetzer Vineyards, the company their grandparents founded which the family no longer owns.

Their Masút Vineyard and Winery is the only winery inside the lines.

“There’s obviously the Goldens,” Fetzer said, naming the family that farms next door. “But we’re the only winery in the AVA.”

Prefer to listen instead? Tune in to Roger Coryell’s audio report as he takes us to Eagle Peak and its only winery, the Masut Vineyard and Winery.

Rows of grapevines with autumn-colored leaves stretch across a dry field, set against a backdrop of forested hills under a clear blue sky.

No valleys

Eagle Peak sits in the upper Russian River watershed. Small creeks on the west side of the watershed come down off the ridges and join Forsythe Creek, and those western tributaries mark the appellation’s boundary, Fetzer said. Mill Creek runs up the middle, with Reeves Canyon Road beside it. Cross the ridge west of the peak, and the water drains to the Big River. Go north toward Willits, and it’s the Eel. A couple of ridges south, it’s the Navarro.

“There are really no valleys in this appellation,” Fetzer said. “It’s all hillside.”

Within a couple of miles, the road climbs out of the vineyards into redwoods, with fairy rings of young trees around the stumps of the old ones. Fetzer called the shift “Guerneville-esque.” From there, he said, the forest runs all the way to the town of Mendocino.

The soils are thin. Most of what Masút farms lower down is a sedimentary, gravelly clay, Fetzer said. Higher up are a few pockets of deeper red soil, weathered from sandstone. Vines on the thin ground stay small, even in blocks planted in the mid-1990s.

“The grapes, you know, they end up being pretty concentrated,” he said. “The yields are generally pretty low.”

The petition that created the appellation said the same in federal terms: What sets the place apart is a marine-influenced climate, strong breezes, mountainous topography and shallow soils that hold little water.

The mountains also stop the fog. Fog comes up the canyons, but Eagle Peak and the ridges around it are tall enough to hold it back, Fetzer said. It’s a windy place, and when offshore winds blow, it can get warm.

When the brothers were building their case, they put weather stations around the appellation and counted the days above 90 degrees. By Fetzer’s recollection, the high stations logged about six in a growing season, the winery about 15 to 20, and a station in Redwood Valley about 60. He said he would have to check the exact numbers.

The growing season is shorter than on the valley floor, he said, and the place stays cold longer.

“In the three seasons that aren’t necessarily the summer,” Fetzer said, the mountain runs cooler than the valley floor “and even parts of Sonoma County.”

Rows of grapevines with autumn-colored leaves stretch across a dry field, set against a backdrop of forested hills under a clear blue sky.
Vines turn red and gold on a hillside vineyard in the Eagle Peak Mendocino County appellation near Redwood Valley, Calif., on Wednesday, Oct. 14, 2026. The appellation is all hillside, with no valley floor, according to Jake Fetzer of Masút Vineyard and Winery. (Roger Coryell/Bay City News)

The neighbors

Masút is the only winery, but other people grow grapes here, too.

Joe and Julie Golden farm Golden Vineyards beside Masút, and their grapes are certified organic, too. The Goldens’ ground has some of the same deep red soil as the top of Masút, Fetzer said, and the couple worked with the Fetzers on the petition.

Farther up Reeves Canyon Road is a small vineyard owned by Dan Kosta, a co-founder of Kosta Browne, the Sonoma County pinot noir house. Kosta is now owner of Convene winery in Sonoma County. Fetzer said they met around 2010 at the World of Pinot Noir annual event, then held at Shell Beach. Kosta was already a big name when he stopped at the Masút table and tasted.

“He goes, ‘Whoa, never heard of you guys,'” Fetzer said.

Kosta later came up the mountain. Fetzer told him about a vineyard in the appellation that would suit him, and Kosta went in on it with a partner, Fetzer said.

Above that, in one of the cooler parts of the appellation, another grower farms cabernet sauvignon that is sometimes picked into November, Fetzer said.

Rows of grapevines stretch across a sunlit field, with a forested hill rising against a clear blue sky.
Eagle Peak, the 2,699-foot summit that gives the Eagle Peak Mendocino County appellation its name, rises above a Masút Vineyard and Winery vineyard block near Redwood Valley, Calif., on Wednesday, Oct. 14, 2026. The appellation’s mountains hold back coastal fog, according to Jake Fetzer of Masút. (Roger Coryell/Bay City News)

A petition, a hobbyist and a decade

In 2005, Fetzer said, he and his father, Bobby Fetzer, were splitting time between the Redwood Valley vineyards and a ranch Bobby had bought in Round Valley, where he was raising organic grass-fed beef and had prepped some fields for vines.

That year, Jake Fetzer saw that someone had petitioned for new appellations around Covelo and Dos Rios. He wondered at first whether his father was behind it, but the petitioner was Ralph Jens Carter, Fetzer said, “who was just doing it for fun. He was like on a mission to create some appellations around the county.”

Fetzer got in touch. The old appellation lines ran right through the family’s vineyard, splitting it between the Redwood Valley AVA and the much larger Mendocino AVA, according to the 2013 federal notice. Neither name described the place, Fetzer said.

“It’s just Mendocino County,” Fetzer said. “And every time I try to describe where we’re at, it always comes back to this appellation that’s just Mendocino County.”

Carter helped him put the petition together, and Fetzer brought in Joe and Julie Golden, whose vineyard was split the same way. The work, he said, taught him the area’s climate, history and weather patterns.

The petition “took us about 10 years,” he said. “But there’s still so much more to do in Mendocino County for the appellations.”

The federal Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau proposed the appellation on June 27, 2013. The petition, filed by Carter on behalf of local growers, listed about 120 acres of vines in 16 commercial vineyards. Two companion petitions redrew the neighbors’ lines: About 1,430 acres came out of the Redwood Valley AVA and about 1,900 out of the Mendocino AVA, and those slices became part of Eagle Peak. Jake and Ben Fetzer signed it, as did John Fetzer of Saracina Vineyards.

The petition named the appellation for a 2,699-foot summit on the U.S. Geological Survey’s map, about 6 miles west of the Redwood Valley Rancheria. Rep. Jared Huffman, whose district includes the area, wrote a letter in support. No one opposed the appellation itself.

Rows of large stainless steel fermentation tanks and wooden barrels are arranged in a winery facility.
Stainless steel tanks and oak barrels fill the Masút Vineyard and Winery building near Redwood Valley, Calif., on Wednesday, Oct. 14, 2026. Each vineyard block at Masút is fermented and aged on its own, according to winemaker Jake Fetzer. (Roger Coryell/Bay City News)

The name fight

The name drew one objection.

In November 2013, after the bureau reopened public comment, a Washington, D.C., attorney, Robert G. Kalik, wrote on behalf of Fetzer Vineyards of Hopland, owned by the Chilean winemaker Viña Concha y Toro. The company didn’t object to the appellation, according to the bureau’s summary of the letter. It objected to the name.

The letter argued that the area was really known as Forsythe Creek or Walker Valley, citing 1910 federal soil surveys and a valley labeled on government maps. It also said buyers would confuse the appellation with the company’s Eagle Peak Merlot, a brand it said it introduced in 1993, and that the company could lose the right to the brand because it couldn’t buy enough grapes from inside the new boundaries.

Jake Fetzer answered for the petitioners three days later. His letter disputed both points, and it noted that the brand had been named for merlot grown at the Fetzer home ranch, in view of Eagle Peak.

The bureau sided with the growers. Its final rule was published Oct. 9, 2014, and took effect Nov. 10. The rule found that the company’s letter offered no evidence the area wasn’t known as Eagle Peak or that anyone currently called it Forsythe Creek or Walker Valley. Old soil surveys didn’t count, the bureau said, because the rules require proof of what a place is called now. Only the full name, Eagle Peak Mendocino County, would be protected on labels, so the company could keep selling Eagle Peak Merlot.

Masút

A person in a blue shirt and cap is sampling wine from a wooden barrel using a small glass.
Jake Fetzer draws a sample from a barrel at Masút Vineyard and Winery near Redwood Valley, Calif., on Wednesday, Oct. 14, 2026. Fetzer said he has been using less new oak, because it is expensive and the wine takes longer to absorb it. (Roger Coryell/Bay City News)

The brothers are grandsons of Barney and Kathleen Fetzer, who started Fetzer Vineyards on their Redwood Valley ranch in 1968 and raised 11 children. The family sold the company to Brown-Forman in 1992 for a reported $82 million. Brown-Forman sold it to Concha y Toro in 2011 for $238 million.

Bobby Fetzer, one of Barney and Kathleen’s sons, was the company’s chief grape buyer. He and his wife, Sheila, bought the ranch in the Russian River headwaters in the early 1990s, and their sons cleared the slopes and planted them in the middle of the decade. Bobby Fetzer drowned in a rafting accident on the Eel River in 2006. He was 50.

The winery says Masút is a Pomo word. In 1908, the anthropologist Samuel Barrett recorded a Pomo village called Masu’t about 3 miles northwest of Calpella.

Masút farms only pinot noir and chardonnay, all certified organic. Some of the original vines Bobby Fetzer planted were Dijon clones, which his son likes because they’re fruit forward. The vineyard also grows Mount Eden, Swan and a Swiss clone called Mariafeld. Swan is such a light producer, he said, that he blends it in early because he never has enough of it.

He also grows a suitcase clone. A suitcase clone is a vine brought home from Europe as cuttings in someone’s luggage, outside the official quarantine, and passed from grower to grower. This one goes by La Tâche, after the Burgundy grand cru vineyard owned by Domaine de la Romanée-Conti.

The idea came from Greg La Follette, a winemaker who bought Masút fruit and became a mentor. La Follette became head winemaker at Flowers Vineyard & Winery on the Sonoma Coast in 1996 and supplied much of the budwood for Van der Kamp Vineyard on Sonoma Mountain.

“He’s like, ‘You gotta get some of this wood here,'” Fetzer said.

Jake Fetzer got his cuttings from Van der Kamp. Van der Kamp got its from Flowers, he said, and Flowers got its from someone else. Masút’s La Tâche grows on a steep hillside block.

Each block is fermented and aged on its own. The best go into the estate pinot noir and the estate chardonnay. The rest go to a second label. The blend changes with the year.

It won’t be “like a Caymus or a Meiomi thing” that tastes the same every year, Jake Fetzer said. “It’s really vintage dependent.”

He has been using less new oak, because it’s expensive and because the wine takes longer to absorb it. He is thinking about gamay noir, bottled young, and maybe pinot blanc.

The operation is mostly the two brothers. Jake Fetzer makes the wine, but he said everyone does whatever the day needs.

“We’re like a small restaurant,” he said. “Everybody steps in when they need to step in.”

Masút isn’t on a tasting route.

“We lay pretty low,” Fetzer said. “We’re kind of hideouts in a way.”

A hard market

Fetzer listed what is weighing on the wine business: a couple of small harvests, buyers who have quit buying grapes to get by on bulk wine, turmoil among distributors and the cost of shipping.

“When the customer’s going, ‘Hey, I want to get two bottles of wine, and I want you to ship it here,’ well, the shipping can be more than the wine,” he said.

“One of the biggest challenges, to be honest, is the negative press, too,” he said. “It’s in dire straits, and it’s the only thing people talk about. And then nobody invests in anything anymore.”

Information on Masút’s wines and wine club is at masut.com, or call 707-485-5466.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *