
Editor’s note: The following is a letter to the editor. The opinions expressed in this letter are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect those of The Mendocino Voice. If you would like to submit a letter to the editor feel free to write to [email protected].Â
Dear Editor:
The Mendocino Railway, also known as the Skunk Train, operates a tourist train over approximately three miles of track in Fort Bragg, along with rail bike excursions. The city should be evaluating the actual operating conditions, safety risks, horn use and impacts on residents—not relying on generalized arguments about freight railroads and federal liability. Due diligence means examining the circumstances that actually exist in Fort Bragg.
Residents asking for quiet zones and reporting excessive horn-blowing are not opposing the tourist train or rail bike operations. They are asking the city to address noise impacts and explore reasonable solutions that allow these activities to continue while respecting the quality of life of people who live nearby. Those are two very different positions, and we should not confuse them.

Fort Bragg City Council, staff and consultants appear to be drawing conclusions before doing the necessary homework. The city should not dismiss the possibility of a quiet zone based on generalized safety concerns, speculative liability or comparisons that do not reflect the actual circumstances in Fort Bragg.
Invoking federal liability requirements does not constitute a meaningful argument against exploring a quiet zone. Federal regulations provide a process for communities to establish quiet zones when specified safety standards are met. Routine horn requirements can be waived in qualifying quiet zones, while engineers retain the authority to sound horns when safety requires it.
If the question is whether a quiet zone can be established safely, let’s discuss the actual safety requirements, engineering solutions, accident data and federal regulations governing quiet zones. The existence of federal horn requirements is not an argument against exploring that option. Let’s debate the merits of the proposal rather than introduce unrelated comparisons.
Where is the comprehensive engineering assessment? Where is the independent safety analysis? Where is the examination of all available options and their actual costs?
The city should be investigating these questions before suggesting that a quiet zone is impractical or too expensive.
Residents deserve facts, professional analysis and a thorough evaluation of alternatives—not assumptions, speculative liability arguments or comparisons that distract from the real issue.
Due diligence means investigating the possibilities, not finding reasons to dismiss them.
Mary Rose Kaczorowski
Fort Bragg
