(Illustration by Joe Dworetzky/Bay City News)

Dear Editor:

Before moving to Fort Bragg a decade ago, I retired from the Department of Transportation, Federal Railroad Administration. In my 16-year career there, it was part of my job to help communities navigate 49 CFR Use of Locomotive Horns at Public Highway-Rail Grade Crossings Part 222, commonly referred to as the Train Horn Rule. This is the rule that allows municipalities to establish quiet zones within their jurisdiction. After my government service, I continued quiet zone work as an independent consultant until 2021.

When I worked for the government, I was not allowed to express an opinion on whether communities should pursue a Quiet Zone. Now retired, I can: Fort Bragg does not need a Quiet Zone.

Here are some facts: Quiet Zones are not quiet. The normal use of the horn is restricted in a quiet zone as the train approaches each grade crossing. However, the horn will still sound for other operational needs and if the employee deems it necessary while operating the train.

The rule does not differentiate between freight, passenger, or tourist railroads. The rule applies to tourist railroads just like freight and passenger; there is no exception.

FILE – The Skunk Train, owned and operated by Mendocino Railway, in Fort Bragg, Calif. on August. 22, 2021. (Sarah Stierch via Bay City News)

There are five consecutive crossings within less than one-quarter mile in town.This equates to approximately 60 seconds of horn use at these crossings each time the train traverses the route to and from Glen Blair. 

Depending on the time of year, the Skunk runs up to eight trains per day. Yes, some are at night, on Fridays and Saturdays, however, the last train terminates at the depot about 11pm. So, just to be clear, locals and visitors will hear a horn for about 16 minutes per 24-hour period due to crossing warning use during the peak tourist time. In the off-season train movement and horn use is drastically reduced.

The train has utilized this track since 1885; that’s more than 140 years. Trains and their horns are nothing new to Fort Bragg.

The horn decibel on the locomotives are within the range legally required by 49 CFR 229.129. 

The railroad is regulated by federal rules. If the city wants the horn silenced, it will be responsible for staff time filing paperwork, any needed upgrades to crossing protection, signage, and liability costs.

Here are some things the city must consider instead of going the quiet zone route: 

There are train horns installed on retrofitted logging trucks/pick-ups/other vehicles of all sizes blowing throughout town daily. How will those be regulated?

As a property owner in the city, I feel it has more pressing problems with aging infrastructure of our roads, empty storefronts in the historical district and beyond.

It should be a priority to encourage more tourists to visit and enjoy our local attractions, shop, occupy hotels and eat at our wonderful cafes and restaurants. It should be another priority to encourage more professionals to move into our area and provide needed services for our community.  

LeeAnn Dickson
Fort Bragg

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *