FILE–The historic Palace Hotel in downtown Ukiah, Calif. in July 2024. Built in 1891, the former hotel has been vacant since 1989. (Google Earth via Bay City News)

UKIAH, CA., 10/9/26 — Palace Hotel owner Tom Carter came to the Ukiah City Council on Wednesday with a promise: a letter, in 10 to 14 days, saying the Palace Hotel is structurally sound. On a 5-0 vote, members put the 1891 hotel back on the Nov. 4 agenda, letter or no letter, with staff to bring options for what the city does next.

“I’m embarrassed to say I don’t know,” Mayor Susan Sher said of the question residents keep asking about what’s happening with the hotel, which the council declared a dangerous building and public nuisance in 2015. “It’s looked the same for about 35 years.” Later: “This is becoming a standing joke in our community … so I’ve just come to the point where I’ve given up, and I don’t really see any realistic possibility.”

Two notices and an engineer’s report

Carter, a contractor who told the council he has been in construction for 55 years, bought Twin Investments LLC, the company whose only asset is the Palace, on Oct. 15, 2024, according to the city’s Palace Hotel page. The building came with two notices of violation.

The first, dated Nov. 3, 2023, ordered the prior owner to file permits to stabilize or demolish the building within 30 days and to put up pedestrian protection. The second, dated April 8, 2024, says that as of that day “no permit application or plan has been submitted,” and it ordered an independent evaluation by a structural engineer, recommendations to stabilize or demolish, and a cost estimate. Both notices are posted on the city’s website and signed by Matt Keizer, the chief building official.

Carter hired the engineer. The report from ZFA Structural Engineers, dated Oct. 30, 2024, and addressed to Carter, says: “The structure is dangerous as it exists.” It called for “an immediate shoring plan” to “avoid additional collapse,” and a winterizing plan “to limit further damage this winter.” It also says no structural analysis of loads or capacities was done.

Sher reminded Carter that his own engineer had found the building dangerous in October 2024. “I’m glad you have a plan in 10 to 14 days,” she said, “but after three years of waiting I think you can understand we’re a little skeptical.”

“You might have been waiting, but I’ve been working,” Carter said.

He listed the work. About 120 tons of debris hauled out. A shoring tower built around the elevator, where the worst collapse was. A new shoring wall in the dining room. Roof repairs, lighting, the sewer lines checked. Keizer confirmed the tower and the wall, both drawn up by an architect.

What the city still doesn’t have, Keizer said, is “a letter saying the building is structurally sound, and it’s no longer a public hazard.” Until it does, he said, work on the building should be limited to structural stability.

Carter said the letter is coming from architect Richard Ruff, and that it’s drafted and “in the hands of attorneys.” Asked how often he’s at the building, he said: “We’re there two, three, four times a month, sometimes more. We’ve been doing out-of-town jobs farther away.”

Asked whether he has investors lined up, he said, “I have some,” and that he is “still talking to several hotels.” The economy, he said, is “probably a little worse” than it was a year ago.

No penalties so far

City Manager Sage Sangiacomo said the city has “not enforced any of the penalty provisions” in city code. Both notices list them: a misdemeanor carrying “a fine of $1,000, six months in the county jail or by both,” and $5,000 for a second violation. He said the city knows of a deed of trust on the building, “we believe it’s 1.2 million dollars,” and has asked to see it.

The deed of trust, recorded with the county the day Carter bought the company, names Jitu Ishwar, who managed the company before Carter, and Paru Ishwar as beneficiaries for $1.2 million.

Sangiacomo also said a finished stabilization letter would let the city take down the pedestrian protection that has been blocking the sidewalk.

Council member Doug Crane, who made the 2023 motion that started the enforcement, laid out what happens if the owner gives up. “We can get our panties in a bunch and push whoever it is, and they can say, … It’s been fun. Goodbye,” he said. “Then who gets to deal with it?” The owner walks away, he said, “and we spend more money tearing the thing down than the land is worth.”

“Why don’t you do a poll in the newspaper and ask the city?” Carter said. “If the public is not behind this, I’ll step aside.”

Unreinforced brick

During public comment, Karen Rifkin told the council the main building dates to 1891 and the School Street building behind it, she believed, to 1914, and that both are unreinforced masonry. The ZFA report describes the 1891 building as “Un-Reinforced Masonry (URM) brick” and the 1914 addition as “unreinforced brick.” A 1929 addition is reinforced concrete.

“It’s not the only unreinforced masonry building in downtown,” Crane said.

Ukiah’s last inventory of unreinforced masonry buildings was done around 2014 and counted about 50, Deputy City Manager Shannon Riley said in a July phone interview with the Voice. Seven had been retrofitted. “We haven’t had any buildings retrofitted since that time,” she said.

Carter told the council the Palace came through an earthquake without damage. “Nothing happened in the Palace, no new cracks, nothing,” he said. An antique lamp fell over, and “that’s the only thing.” He said Riley and a city building inspector both visited afterward.

The Palace comes back before the council Nov. 4.

The council meets in the Civic Center Council Chamber, 300 Seminary Ave., Ukiah, and on Zoom. Wednesday’s meeting started at 5:15 p.m.

Join the Conversation

11 Comments

  1. Oh please. This city council, finally we have someone who has been cleaning out tons of waste, reinforcing, stabilizing the building, and they are acting like nothing has been done. Where was the city for all these years allowing the past owners to get away with neglecting the building. They gave Eladia Laines so much praise for nothing. I went to the social at the palace where they explained all they were going to do big plans, with some of the city council, who are still with the city, all into it, celebrating this big plan. What a bunch of panglossianism.

  2. The city doesn’t have a great track record on “modernization, as can be seen in the old courthouse, soon to be abandoned and possibly torn down. What a waste. It’s ugly, but it is still functional, and it also like the Palace, showed no damage after the earthquake. The Palace should be restored. It is a pretty good looking building and is in harmony with some of the other older buildings downtown. Yeah it’s expensive but it would be worth it, for the integrity of the town. Another hideous modern building would look tacky and weird.

  3. The city got tough on Eladia Laines 20 years after she bought it. This is how the city cares for a Ukiah cornerstone building on the National Register of Historic Places. Good job, nope.

    1. “1989–1990 Tax Sale: After falling into deep financial distress and closure, the 60,000+ square-foot 1891 landmark was put on the county block for unpaid taxes. In 1990, a group of investors—including Marin County resident Eladia Laines (or Ganulin)—purchased the property at a county tax auction for $115,000.”

      – Sounds like even in the 1980s the business model of being a hotel was failing.

  4. It’s not worth saving. Tear it down and make way for some shops with the bricks used for a nice promenade. Maybe offer some incentives for local businesses to move in. Even that is risky in today’s economy. Anything short of demolition is a losing proposition.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *