(Illustration by Joe Dworetzky/Bay City News)

As a patient, community member, and employee of a federally qualified health center in rural Northern California, I strongly oppose Proposition 44.

Prop 44 may sound reasonable when described as requiring healthcare organizations to spend 90% of their funds on direct patient care. But that simple formula does not reflect the reality of providing healthcare in rural communities.

I receive care at a health center in Laytonville, a community of approximately 1,152 residents. Despite our small population, this health center serves more than 3,100 unique patients and provides over 23,000 patient visits annually. People travel from across Mendocino County and beyond for care because healthcare options in this region are limited.

For many of us, our community health center is not simply the most convenient option. It may be the only realistic option.

That is why Prop 44 concerns me. Patient care is about much more than what happens inside an exam room.

A patient cannot receive appropriate treatment if staff cannot access their medical records. They cannot see a specialist if someone does not process their referral. They cannot make an appointment if they have no transportation. Providers cannot safely care for patients without functioning technology, maintained facilities, accurate records, quality programs, care coordination and the employees who keep all of those systems working.

The front of the Long Valley Health Clinic building in Laytonville, Calif., in the fall of 2025. (Long Valley Health Clinic via Bay City News)

These services are not administrative luxuries. They are part of patient care.

This is particularly important in rural communities, where patients may travel long distances for medical, dental, behavioral health and other services. Many are seniors, people with disabilities, low-income families, and others facing significant barriers to care. Transportation assistance, case management, referrals and care coordination can determine whether a patient actually receives treatment or goes without it.

As an employee, I see firsthand that every department contributes to caring for our patients. As a patient, I depend on that entire system working.

A rigid spending mandate that fails to recognize these realities could force community health centers to reduce the very services and infrastructure that allow rural patients to access care. In communities like Laytonville, there is no easy replacement if those services disappear.

California should protect healthcare dollars, but it should not do so with a formula that misunderstands how healthcare is actually delivered.

Before voting on Proposition 44, I urge Californians to think about rural patients and the community health centers that serve them. Quality of patient care requires providers and nurses, but it also requires transportation, referrals, medical records, technology, facilities, care coordination and the people who make all of those services work.

Please vote NO on Proposition 44. Rural healthcare is already difficult enough to access. We should not make it harder.

Shantil Ferguson

Laytonville

Join the Conversation

2 Comments

  1. Maybe we should make a proposition that says every voter in the state is required to live for a minimum of 5 years in a rural setting and to hold a job within that settling that is their sole source of income before they become eligible to vote.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *