The Mendocino County Administration Center, located at 501 Low Gap Road in Ukiah, Calif., on Tuesday, May 6, 2025. (Sydney Fishman/Bay City News)

MENDOCINO CO., 11/18/26 — If you rent out a vacation home in Mendocino County and you’ve never signed up to pay the county’s lodging tax, a private tax firm may come looking for you.

The Board of Supervisors voted unanimously Tuesday to move ahead with the plan to catch short-term rental tax evaders. Treasurer-Tax Collector Chamise Cubbison is to bring back a contract with HdL Companies, a specialized auditing firm based in Brea, California The firm would search rental websites for places that aren’t registered with the county and contact the owners. It would also process tax returns and payments and run audits. It already collects lodging tax and does audits for the city of Ukiah, Cubbison said.

Supervisor John Haschak asked if the plan would get the county closer to collecting all the lodging tax it’s owed.

“That’s the idea,” Cubbison said.

Right now, no county staff audit the payments. Cubbison’s Nov. 2 memo to the board says the Auditor-Controller’s Office hasn’t had the staff to audit lodging tax payments since 2020. It says HdL’s preliminary data indicates “there are likely about 100-150 short-term rentals that are not currently enrolled with the county.” The memo calls that data “very preliminary.” Many listings show up on more than one website, it says.

What Airbnb does next door

Outside city limits in Humboldt, Sonoma and Trinity counties, the lodging tax is part of an Airbnb reservation. Airbnb collects it and sends the money to the county. But their reporting is opaque, according to Cubbison, possibly a reason that Mendocino has not engaged the site to collect and pay the county as it does the other three counties.

In Mendocino County, it’s up to the owner or a managing agent. The county code says each lodging operator must register with the tax collector, collect a 10% tax from guests and send it in. Operators also owe a 1% business improvement district assessment. That money pays for tourism promotion.

Airbnb’s published list of where it collects the tax has no entry for Mendocino County or any city in it. Vrbo’s list has the same three neighboring counties and no Mendocino entry.

Counties call the deals with Airbnb and Vrbo voluntary collection agreements. Cubbison told the board what she sees as their drawback. Under those deals, she said, a county can’t audit what the platforms collect or pay. “You essentially receive the money, no questions asked,” she said.

She told the board that Airbnb is “threatening lawsuits against any county who tries to push that,” meaning the right to audit. She didn’t name a county or a lawsuit.

Airbnb hadn’t answered written questions the Mendocino Voice sent Nov. 13, including why it has no collection agreement with Mendocino County.

Humboldt County’s 2016 agreement with Airbnb does let the county audit Airbnb itself, based on its tax returns and records. Sonoma County’s 2016 summary of its own agreement says the same. Neither county can go straight to individual hosts or guests on those bookings. It has to audit Airbnb first, and if for some reason, the matter is still unresolved, only then can it go to the hosts or guests. Humboldt’s agreement also limits the county to auditing one 12-month stretch in any four years. Sonoma’s summary says the county can still audit a host after a complaint.

Cubbison said some local lodgings take bookings on their own websites as well as on Airbnb or Vrbo. She isn’t confident every rental runs through the platforms.

What owners can expect

Under the HdL plan, the firm would audit each of the county’s larger lodging properties once every three years. It would also audit at least 10 short-term rentals a year, at $2,000 each.

Owners who don’t cooperate could be referred to county lawyers, who could file a lien, a legal claim against the property, or take them to court, Cubbison said. So far, she said, “We haven’t had the staff resources to pursue those.”

If the contract is signed by Dec. 31, HdL could start collecting with the quarter that ends March 31, 2027, the memo says.

What it costs

Mendocino County collected $8.77 million in lodging tax in the 2025-26 fiscal year, including a tax on camping, a tax collector’s table shows. An average of 857 lodging operators, not counting 36 campgrounds, were registered to pay it.

Collecting the lodging tax and tourism assessment cost the county $130,315 that year. That’s from Cubbison’s cost sheet. With HdL, the sheet estimates $272,691 this budget year. That’s $135,435 for HdL plus the county’s own staff and the service it now pays to track rental listings online. The estimate for the year after is $221,930. Cubbison’s recommendation counts on more lodging tax coming in to cover the added cost.

Scott Schneider is interim executive director of Visit Mendocino County. He said the tourism group wants better numbers out of the change. He named average nightly rates and occupancy. “I think as an organization, we are fully in support,” he said. He also said Ukiah uses HdL and that “they’ve had their own issues with them.” He said he understands from talking with Cubbison that the firm has improved and expanded its services.

Supervisor Ted Williams backed the plan and asked the board to drop the county business license altogether. HdL’s proposal would also take over business license renewals. “We don’t make any money on it. It’s anti-business,” Williams said.

How neighboring counties did it

Humboldt County supervisors approved their agreement with Airbnb in May 2016. The company was to start collecting that July 1, a Humboldt County staff report says. Sonoma County’s agreement was to take effect Jan. 1, 2017, a Sonoma County board document says. In the 2024-25 fiscal year, Airbnb paid Sonoma County $10.07 million, about a third of the $30.78 million in lodging tax the county took in. Those are figures the county released in response to a public records request.

Having the platforms collect the tax came up at a county public meeting on short-term rentals in Ukiah on April 30, 2025. One of the recommendations was: “Require STR platforms to collect and remit TOT directly to the county.” STR is short for short-term rental and TOT for transient occupancy tax, the formal name of the lodging tax. The county’s summary of that meeting went to the supervisors with their Feb. 3 agenda.

“That doesn’t mean that we can’t enter into a contract and still have both services if we decide we want to do it,” Cubbison said of the platform agreements.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *