
The opinions expressed in this piece do not necessarily reflect the views of The Mendocino Voice. We value the diverse opinions of our readers and we welcome robust, wide-ranging thoughts and ideas on subjects relevant to Mendocino County. Opinion pieces can be sent to [email protected].
When you walk along Main Street in the town of Mendocino, you can still see what generations of painters, photographers and visitors already know: no single feature of this town’s skyline is more distinctive, more painted or more photographed than its water towers. Entire books have been written on them. Sadly, fewer than half of the town’s historic water towers remain, and none is more visible or recognizable than the one left standing on Main Street.
In June, a Mendocino County Superior Court judge sustained a demurrer and dismissed, without a trial, our organizations’ challenge to the county’s approval of the demolition of the last water tower standing on Main Street. We are appealing that ruling to the California Court of Appeal. We want the public to understand what is at stake — because it is bigger than one structure.
Our organizations, the Mendocino Preservation Fund, along with Citizens to Save the Water Tower, sued in the public interest after the County Board of Supervisors voted to allow demolition of the 120-year-old water tower at 45040 Main Street. The Mendocino Historical Review Board —charged with protecting the town’s historic character — had denied the demolition application not once but multiple times, most recently in December 2024. The Board of Supervisors overruled its own preservation board and approved the demolition by a vote of 4-1. The lone dissenting vote came from the supervisor who represents Mendocino and its residents, who urged support for the Historical Review Board’s repeated informed findings.

It is disturbing that four supervisors with no district connection to this town voted to override the one supervisor whose own constituents would live with the result, choosing to ignore the informed rulings of our local review board. They failed to enforce clearly articulated guidelines protecting structures in a National Historic District that Mendocino has held for 55 years, inconsistent with the county’s own Historic District Ordinance. They voted to demolish a historic structure that helps bring in tourism dollars for the entire county. And they did so by misapplying a “categorical exemption” applicable to fences and garages to skip the environmental review and consideration of alternatives required by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) before a historic or cultural resource can be destroyed.
No project environmental review was conducted. No alternatives were studied nor mitigation considered. The public notice for the project hearing described replacement of “an existing water tower staircase attached to a commercial structure with a new staircase” — failing to describe the actual project: demolition of a water tower that has stood on Mendocino’s skyline since 1904.
CEQA protects resources of cultural, aesthetic, or architectural significance to a community. Mendocino’s vanishing water towers are just such a resource, not anonymous infrastructure. They are documented, photographed, painted and beloved. They look like nothing else in California.
We contend the staircase at issue can be replaced without affecting the water tower at all.
This case is about more than one water tower. It affects the ongoing protection of historic Mendocino by applicable legal protections rather than the goodwill of whoever happens to own them. Our water towers should not disappear quietly, without environmental review or public disclosure that a loss of a historic structure is contemplated. Each loss makes the next one easier as the county’s Historical Review Board acknowledged again and again. We want our community to understand what’s happening and why.
The Mendocino Preservation Fund, a California public-benefit nonprofit organization, formed to protect the architectural and cultural history of the town of Mendocino.
