
Editor’s note: The following is a letter to the editor. The opinions expressed in this letter are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect those of The Mendocino Voice. If you would like to submit a letter to the editor feel free to write to [email protected].
Dear Editor:
On October 7, Tom Carter came to the Ukiah City Council meeting stating he would be getting a letter of approval from Ruff and Associates regarding the building formerly known as the Palace Hotel. He would have the letter to the city in 10-14 days, and it would state that the unreinforced brick masonry perimeter walls, built in 1891 and 1914, were safe.
He also acknowledged, as he has done since purchasing Twin Investments, LLC (whose only asset is the Palace Hotel) on October 15, 2024, that he has no investors.
This letter references information from my book, “The History of Ukiah’s Palace Hotel,” of potential costs for bringing the building up to safety standards and the costs for renovation to develop the building as a functioning enterprise.
In the year 2000, during the time Eladia Laines owned the building (1990-2017), the City of Ukiah received a Community Development Block Grant for $35,000 for technical assistance to prepare the Palace Hotel Reuse Study.

In 2001, Applied Development Economics and Mogavero Notestine Associates presented the results. Costs for renovation were estimated at $4,502,375 (about $8.5 million today) including $2 million for a restaurant; $575,000 for a 25-room boutique hotel; $880,000 for 34 residential apartments or office suites; $250,000 for ground floor retail shops or offices; $850,000 for engineering and architectural fees and permits; and an additional $1.5 million for a seismic retrofit. Seismic risk evaluations noted the unreinforced masonry posed serious safety risks and the report assessed how to safely tie new design alternatives into a stable, retrofitted shell. The report was accepted by city staff.
The $20,000 Seismic Analysis Study completed by Point 2 Structural Engineers and Applied Development Economics in 2002 recommended three options: an upgrade for all structures for life and safety conditions for $1.5 million; upgrade the 1891 and 1914 structures and demolish the 1929 building for $1.2 million; or upgrade the 1891 building and demolish the other two buildings for $1 million. The report recommended the first option and, with additional costs for earthquake retrofitting, the total estimate came to $3 million (about $5.6 million today). The council took no immediate action on the report.
In 2004 the City hired Dana Burwell for $6,000 to do an appraisal of the building. He said the Palace was a black hole for profit. He said, “No matter what you do, you will not make a profit on the hotel.” Because the property had negative returns, the only value was on the 20,000 square foot site valued at $310,000 (about $550,000 today).
Karen Rifkin
Ukiah

So……..
Basically nothings gonna happen unless a benevolent rich person takes a loss
Sell it for the land value minus the demolition costs. Fixed the problem.
Hard to speculate about the future based on such old studies and opinions quoted in this letter. But to fill out the picture of past studies more fully, consider this… About a dozen years after the 2004 appraisal mentioned by the letter writer, the City of Ukiah (in 2016) retained CBRE Hotels to conduct a study of the potential market demand and estimated financial performance for a proposed hotel to be located in Historic Downtown Ukiah. What was their conclusion after this much more recent and exhaustive economic analysis? “There is sufficient market demand to support the development of a 75-room, upscale hotel” in the downtown. (The full study acan be found on the City’s website.) Perhaps the best thing the City (and us armchair commenters) can do is to recognize there’s a new owner (Tom Carter) who is working toward bringing the Palace Hotel back to life. He knows all this history quite well, and he’s still devoting himself to saving this historic landmark. He did it with the Tallman Hotel in Upper Lake, so let’s give him the benefit of the doubt and thank him for putting his money where others put their mouths.
Thank you for being the voice of reason.
I believe that the study completed by CBRE (who is the largest commercial real estate corporation in the world) is more valuable than that of an individual appraiser.
Value is determined by what someone is willing to pay, not armchair opinions.
Look at what has happened to Healdsburg over the last 60 years. It had gone from nothing but the pig and prune farmers to a highly sought after 5 star world class destination.
No reason why the Ukiah economy should not benefit from similar circumstances. Give the new owner a chance before naysaying the project to the burn pile.
I was born and raised in Ukiah, as was my dad before me. I would love to see someone get this ” grand old lady ” restored to usefulness.
dearest urbanist
cleanup is many times the value of the land (lot)
reading isnt your super power
I said what I said. Reading and research are not the same thing my friend. It might sell for peanuts, which is what it is worth at this point.
No need to be dismissive or rude. You and I both want this demolished.
Had this been converted to a upscale Hotel 30 yrs ago
Ukiah would already be resembling Healdsburg rather than dog patch
We’ve been demographically hamstringed for long enough
Let’s get behind Tom Carter and open a new chapter for Ukiah
For the love of Pete, how many more decades of inaction until someone can make some productive use out of that derelict piece of property?!
Regardless of what Richard Ruff’s thinking is on this dangerous structure, it has been authoritatively established that the only possible way to do an incredibly expensive seismic retrofit is if some billionaire falls in love with it and is willing to lose many millions of dollars on the project. AIN’T EVER GOING TO HAPPEN! Time to finally give up on this fever dream that’s so many people have, despite having no intention of investing themselves.
I agree with Dennis. Tom Carter has shown he’s willing to do the work to restore the Palace to a new beginning. Give the man a chance to do that. The City of Ukiah has given so many owners over the years so much time to do nothing. This takes time and money, it’s not a quick fix.
Tear it down and rebuild with an extra story like they did with the Mendocino Hotel.
Tom Carter without question is one of the best builders of both houses and restoration projects in Northern California..His successful projects includes, The Tallman hotel in upperlake, The Cisco winery in Nice. As well as the old now restored hotel in Lucerne on hwy 20. His vision and old school methods of work are over the top amazing, he covets and respects the old school craftsmen of the past and emulates their methods and techniques with amazing results. He will re-purpose old redwood and lumber, at every opportunity as opposed to using new wood, with amazing results…His crew is Top shelf, and their respect for the environment and it’s resources is beyond the pale..Give this man time and you will not be disappointed.