UKIAH, CA., 10/29/26 — Ukiah is supposed to finish closing its old landfill on Vichy Springs Road by Saturday. It won’t. The city is sending a letter Wednesday asking for one more year.
“I’m looking at a draft letter to extend that right now,” Tim Eriksen, the city’s public works director, said in a phone interview Wednesday. “So we will be sending that out today.”
Closing a landfill doesn’t mean it shuts its gates. That happened 25 years ago. The landfill stopped taking garbage in September 2001. Ukiah’s trash now goes to the transfer station on Taylor Drive, which C&S Waste Solutions runs for the city.
In state law, “closure” means sealing the old dump for good. About 40 acres of buried trash get a permanent cover. The city’s website lists the rest: grading to keep storm water from soaking in, drainage, and systems to control landfill gas and check the groundwater. Then the city has to inspect and maintain the site for 30 years.
Ukiah’s cover will be ClosureTurf, a plastic sheet topped with artificial grass and weighed down with sand, not a clay cap.
The city ran the landfill from 1955 to September 2001, according to the city’s website. A 2013 Mendocino County grand jury report on it was titled “A landfill that refused to die.”
State rules gave the city two years to seal it, the grand jury wrote. Twelve years later, in 2013, it still wasn’t done. That year the county’s Environmental Health division ordered the city to cap the landfill. That order has set eight deadlines since, starting with March 2014. This Saturday, Oct. 31, is the latest.
Why it’s late again
Eriksen said the holdup is a permit from the North Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board. The board has to approve rules for how the site handles water that touches the waste. Those rules are called waste discharge requirements, or WDRs.
“This entire thing is really the result of the water board, the regional board, not issuing our WDRs,” Eriksen said.
The city has met with the water board, the county, CalRecycle — the state’s Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery — and the local air district for about three years, he said. The meetings now happen every other month.
The work has to happen in dry months. Eriksen said the permits for this kind of job usually allow work no earlier than May 1 and require it to be done by Oct. 31. The water board permit won’t come in time for this year’s season, so the earliest the work can start is May 2027. And it has to start right on time, Eriksen said: “You have to be May 1st, all guns blazing, ready to go, all material ordered.”
A second lawsuit could push it back further. In 2020, Vichy Springs Resort, a historic mineral springs resort on Vichy Springs Road, sued the city over the closure plan. The suit fought the choice of ClosureTurf over clay. A Mendocino County judge ruled for the city in May 2023, and a state appeals court agreed in December 2024.
Gilbert Aschoff, whose Vichy Springs Resort sits next to the landfill, said in a phone interview Wednesday that the city’s environmental review studied only ClosureTurf and never priced it against a clay cover, though the site has its own clay. “They never did a cost comparison directly with clay versus plastic,” he said. He called ClosureTurf a temporary cover that will have to be replaced someday. He said the water board makes the city set money aside for that, which it wouldn’t have to do for clay. In 2018, at the water board’s request, the city agreed to count a possible replacement of the plastic sheet in the money it must set aside for the landfill, according to a September 2025 letter from the city’s lawyer. “Remember that $21 million is a temporary cover,” he said.
His other complaint is the Russian River, a drinking water source for Santa Rosa and other cities downstream. Rain runs off a plastic cover instead of soaking in, Aschoff said, and its plastic blades will wear out, break off and wash down a stream into the river. “We don’t need 40 acres of plastic bleeding off into a stream into the Russian River,” he said.
Eriksen said Aschoff has told the water board he will sue again when the permit goes before the board.
“If that happens, that would then, I mean, you know, that would probably be a two-year-ish movement,” Eriksen said.
In a September 2025 letter, the city’s lawyer told the water board that the board had insisted the lawsuit be settled before it could issue the permit. The letter said that if the board “has been swayed by Vichy Springs’ threats of litigation,” those threats are barred, because the courts already decided the same issues.
What it costs and who pays
The city’s estimate to close the landfill is $21.1 million, according to a Sept. 16 city report. A year earlier it was $13.4 million. Adding the 30 years of upkeep and money set aside for cleanup, the total is about $31.4 million, up from $23.3 million.
In 2013, the grand jury reported that the city’s budget projected $5.08 million in reserve for closure.
Most of the $21.1 million is the construction contract, estimated at $16.9 million. The rest is other closure costs plus 20% extra for surprises. Close to $10 million of the job is materials that have to be bought before work starts, Eriksen said. The city has to advertise and award the contract before any of that is ordered, and whoever buys the materials needs to know the city will pay them back. If a new lawsuit isn’t settled by around the new year, Eriksen said, there isn’t time to rebid the job and be ready by May 1.
City staff plan to pay for it with savings, a fee on garbage at the transfer station and possibly new borrowing, according to the September report. The city is also looking for grants.
The fee is charged on every ton of garbage dumped at the transfer station. It was $2 a ton in 2016. Eriksen said it’s now $14.
No change to the fee is going to the city council this month, Eriksen said. But a new cost estimate for the landfill will change the transfer station rate, he said. That will change what Ukiah homes and businesses pay for curbside pickup. The city is working to keep the new rate “as lean as possible but covers the cost of closing the landfill ultimately,” he said.
What happens Saturday
Under the county’s order, missing a deadline can bring fines of up to $5,000 a day for each violation, or up to $10,000 a day if a court orders them. The order also says the county won’t seek fines if the city shows the county and CalRecycle it has made an effort to comply.
The landfill has been on the state’s list of sites that break minimum state standards since March 2012, for not closing on time.
One deep testing well for landfill gas, near the south edge, measured methane at 8% to 60% from 2017 on. State rules call for action at 5%. A test on Oct. 2 found no methane in that well, according to a report by EBA Engineering, the city’s consultant. Cost estimates for the next two phases of gas work will come after the first phase is done, according to an April city report.
Eriksen has run Ukiah’s public works department since at least 2013, when the grand jury asked him to respond to its report. He said the city council will know a lot more about the landfill once work starts.
“When we go to construction, there will be a million things that go wrong,” Eriksen said. “We had to make a lot of assumptions when we did the final closure plans. There will be change orders. … Some of them will be terrifying.” Some of those will have to go to the council, he said.
If the water board issues the permit in time and no one sues, Eriksen said, the work could start next May.

Residents are already paying through the nose for garbage. Gate attendants at the transfer station have been purposely sending truck loads through the scales to bring in more money. C & S own website states loads 5 yards and over go through the scales. I’ve been sent through the scales with only 2 yards just because I had certain items in my load. It can’t be left up gate attendants to pick and choose who they send through the scales. Has anyone else felt they were overcharged by C & S waste? Speak up.