Flooding in north Noyo Harbor on Thursday, Jan. 5, 2023. High surf followed an atmospheric river that brought heavy rain and flooding to Mendocino County on Jan. 4. (Kate Fishman/Bay City News)

MENDOCINO CO., 10/6/26 — Mendocino County wants to clear flood-prone creeks before this winter’s El Niño storms. On Tuesday, county staff told the Board of Supervisors that one creek could take up to 18 months and about $1 million just to permit.

Although Gov. Gavin Newsom declared a statewide El Niño emergency Sept. 21, the declaration carries no funding to address the issue, Travis Kilmer, the county’s chief recovery resiliency officer, told the board. “The state was very clear with us,” he said. “There are no funds we can tap into through that at this point.”

Because nothing has been damaged yet, the county can’t claim state disaster assistance either, Kilmer said. If the storms bring serious flooding, the county will have to proclaim a new emergency to ask for that help.

Interim Chief Executive Officer Sara Pierce made her own emergency proclamation Sept. 29, which the board voted unanimously to ratify at Tuesday’s board meeting. Pierce told the board that staff asked state, federal and local partners what it would take for the county to go into its waterways and clear debris. Using one creek that floods often as the example, she said the work would need eight to 10 studies, seven or eight permits and approvals, nine to 18 months, and about $1 million for planning and permitting before a contractor is hired. With no state or federal money, that would come from the general fund.

Supervisor Ted Williams asked whether the creek was in Hopland. The answer was yes.

“The storm doesn’t respect CEQA,” Williams said. “If we have to wait 18 months, the storm will have already passed by.” He asked staff to push the governor’s office and the state Office of Emergency Services to waive the process for counties under the emergency. “You can’t wait till you have it flooded to get a D9 in there,” referring to a 50-ton Caterpillar D9 bulldozer.

From what staff understood, the state has the option to expedite permits, but that conversation hasn’t happened yet, county staff told the board, and the only way to bypass the process would be in the middle of a true disaster. The agencies involved include the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the North Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board, the state Department of Fish and Wildlife and Caltrans, county staff said.

Supervisor Madeline Cline said she doesn’t expect a waiver. The governor’s office has asked the state Natural Resources Agency to report what it can waive or streamline, she said, and the California State Association of Counties has pushed for more resources and fewer requirements. Cline said she’s  had help from Assemblymember Chris Rogers’ staff and meets with the counties association the week of Oct. 12.

“The state is putting us in a position to be reactive instead of proactive,” Cline said. “Homes are going to be flooded,” she said, adding that she is extremely concerned about the school in Hopland. Residents have offered to bring their own bulldozers if the county could get the permits, she said.

Orange traffic cones surround a metal table holding a mound of gravel or asphalt mix on wet pavement, with a red utility bin, work trucks, and a utility trailer in a tree-lined lot during rainy weather.
The sandbag station next to Willits Police Department in Willits, Calif. on Wednesday, Jan 31, 2024. (Kate B. Maxwell via Bay City News)

What the county is doing

Kilmer listed off what the county can do:

  • Buy flood-fight materials with a state Department of Water Resources flood grant. The county is trying to stage one cache in Ukiah, one in the Hopland area and, Kilmer said, probably two on the coast, in Manchester and Point Arena. The same grant is paying for a county flood plan, which won’t be finished before this winter.
  • Find out whether the Department of Water Resources can sell or supply sand and sandbags, and try to get them out before fire departments ask, instead of after.
  • Meet Friday with the Sheriff’s Office and the Office of Emergency Services to go over historic flood maps and pick areas of concern. Pierce said that includes overlaying maps from the 2005 flood.
  • Hold the county’s annual pre-winter meeting with cities, fire departments, state agencies and the National Weather Service on Oct. 15.

Pierce said the greatest impact on the coast will likely come during the king tides, which fall Nov. 24-26, Dec. 23-25 and Jan. 21-22. Williams said the county should warn the visitor-serving businesses that put guests close to sea level now, not during the storms. This isn’t the season to invite people from out of the county to park trailers there, he said, because the county doesn’t have the resources to respond to flooded trailers. Pierce said the Office of Emergency Services’ weekly social media posts will focus on El Niño over the coming month.

Williams asked whether staff could document road conditions before the storms so that washouts could be claimed for federal aid afterward. Pierce said staff time is already being tracked, and that Transportation Director Howard Dashiell will be part of those conversations.

The proclamation adopted by the board says a local emergency exists throughout the county and asks the state Office of Emergency Services to make disaster assistance available. Nobody spoke during public comment.

What the roads department and the scientists have said

Dashiell said in a Sept. 14 email that his department has nothing extra for this winter. He wrote that the department “will do what we can just as we do in any other winter preparation.” Even with more money, spending restricted road funds on channel work outside the right of way would be illegal, and any agency doing that work would need permits, he wrote.

Crews will clean ditches and culverts before storms, Dashiell wrote, but a clean ditch still backs up when the water downstream is high. Past floods have hit hardest along the Russian River and its tributaries at Hopland, Talmage, Vichy Springs, Redwood Valley and Potter Valley, and on the floodplains of the Willits and Covelo valleys, he wrote. The department has about one road worker for every 25 miles of its 1,014 miles of road and no full-time overnight patrol.

Daniel Swain, a climate scientist at the California Institute for Water Resources at University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources, said in a Sept. 14 phone interview that an El Niño this strong makes a wet winter more likely across nearly all of California, Mendocino County included. It doesn’t guarantee flooding, he said.

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s Climate Prediction Center on Sept. 10 put the chances of a very strong El Niño this fall and winter at greater than 90%. In the nine strong or very strong El Niño years since 1950, the North Coast had three wetter-than-normal winters, three drier and three near normal, the county Office of Emergency Services said Sept. 21, citing the National Weather Service.

For the first 24 days of September, the water at NOAA’s Arena Cove tide gauge came in an average of 6.7 inches higher than predicted, according to the agency’s preliminary readings.

Higher water this winter is “pretty definite,” John Largier, a UC Davis oceanographer and former director of the Bodega Marine Laboratory, said in a Sept. 30 phone interview. “Exactly how much is uncertain.”

Mark Merrifield, who directs the Scripps Center for Climate Change Impacts and Adaptation at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography, said in a Sept. 25 phone interview that El Niño adds half a foot to a foot on top of the tide. NOAA predicts a 7.62-foot high tide at Arena Cove on Dec. 24. Its threshold for minor flooding there is 7.75 feet. Low-lying areas “particularly around harbors or river outlets” are the vulnerable spots, Merrifield said. Largier counted five things that can raise the water at once: king tides, the long-term rise in sea level, El Niño, river water running to the sea and the weather. “If you get the perfect storm, it will be really bad,” he said. “If they don’t all align, then it might be okay.”

County road closures are posted here. Preparedness information is at MendoReady.org.

Join the Conversation

9 Comments

  1. Surprised you didn’t mention the Garcia river, which has a low bridge over it, which floods and is closed for days or sometimes a week or so at a time, just about every year.

    1. They sort of mention it “ The county is trying to stage one cache in Ukiah, one in the Hopland area and, Kilmer said, probably two on the coast, in Manchester and Point Arena.”
      But not as much focus.

  2. classic mendo
    too little too late
    too bad we couldnt find our asses on fire in the dark with both hands

    leadership starts from the top
    and was brought there by the nuckle draggers on the bottom

    so much winning

    1. This is a ploy to embezzle millions from next year as well nino ruins homes and schools this year. Not sure why all the farmers offering their own equipment to do it for free this year when the county can’t embezzle from FREE. I have three separate family members that own enough rigs to do it themselves for FREE, LEGIT COMPANIES!. Mendocino county says there is no free in embezzlent. I need to show up to what ever meetings the officials have. I would be saying shit like that constantly accusing everyone. There’s a reason for this, I’m a shit kicker and can go through five men easy, I don’t let embezzlement/money do the talking for me.

  3. All I hear is 18 months to embezzle the flood money, can’t save anyone’s homes or schools until they have enough embezzlement money laying around. The residents of this county have the tools and are will to provide but there is no embezzlement money to be has with out millions of dollars being spoken about. How about all the residents with the equipment just to do it? Bring your guns and rifles and get it done, what’s the police going or do? Shoot down our agriculture farmers? Nope, because then I and the rest of Mendocino will take the police out! And not to dinner. This is how you make change, not by sitting back and watching these fat cooks make ways to get rich on running fucking tractors down a creek. Fucking retards

    1. OK Keyboard warrior. Maybe try proofreading your posts if you want anyone to take you seriously. You don’t even realize “without” is one word yet you expect us to let you and your buddies do something important like clear a creek of debris properly? No doubt you’d end up creating outlet channels and help spread the water into neighboring properties.

    2. Guns and rifles won’t stop the flooding or clear the debris…..
      But do go on cleatus with your big spineless talk

  4. Feliz Creek is down the street from us. PG&E is there strengthening a pipeline. I’m hopeful that work will be completed soon as I read the article and am concerned. To the person that wants to bulldoze- I get frustration with red tape. I appreciate your desire to help because it’s helps greatly when people help.
    The reason a study is so important is to avoid ruptured pipelines which we know can be deadly. There has to be great care and planning for Feliz Creek.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *