The City of Ukiah logo, located in Ukiah, California. (City of Ukiah via Bay City News)

UKIAH, CA., 11/19/26 — Kerri and Chuck Vau got a city building permit last year to put four shipping containers on land they own on Jackson Avenue. They set two in place. Then a neighbor complained, and the city said the permit should never have been issued.

On Thursday afternoon, the Ukiah City Council sided with the city. It voted 3-0 to reject the Vaus’ appeal.

Mari Rodin, a council member, made the motion and Vice Mayor Juan Orozco seconded it. Rodin, Orozco and Mayor Susan Sher voted yes. Douglas Crane, a council member, abstained. Heather Criss, the fifth council member, was absent.

With the appeal rejected, a city order from August stands. That order directs the city to cancel the permit and refund the permit fee, and it tells the Vaus to remove the containers, according to the city staff report.

The motion also adopted written findings that back Community Development Director Craig Schlatter’s decision. City Attorney Darcy Vaughn drafted them, and council members spent most of Thursday’s session editing the wording. Before the vote, Sher reopened the public hearing. No one spoke.

A council decision can generally be challenged in court within 90 days, according to the meeting agenda.

What the fight was about

The council heard the appeal Wednesday night in a public hearing that ran close to three hours.

Ukiah’s zoning code allows “accessory buildings” in single-family neighborhoods. It doesn’t list shipping containers. Much of the hearing was about whether a 20-foot steel container counts as an accessory building, the way a backyard shed does.

Schlatter told the council the city has an open code enforcement case on another shipping container elsewhere in Ukiah.

The staff report gives this timeline. Kerri Vau applied in March 2025 to install four containers, each 8 feet by 20 feet, “for storage only.” The building division issued the permit April 14, 2025. The city extended it in April 2026, records released under a public records request show.

Neighbor Jim Dayton emailed Schlatter on May 11, 2026, about the first container, which sits near his home. On July 22, Schlatter wrote to Vau and Dayton that the permit should not have been issued before he reviewed the use. On Aug. 5, he was told a second container was in place. On Aug. 6, he ruled that containers are not an appropriate use in the zone.

Vau appealed Aug. 17. That put the removal order on hold, Schlatter said in an email.

A permit issued, then pulled back

At the hearing, Schlatter said a planning manager signed off on the permit in error. Under the code, he said, only the director can decide whether a use the code doesn’t list belongs in the zone.

The Vaus’ attorney, Brian Momsen, said the containers are storage buildings like any shed and were allowed from the start. He said the couple spent about $5,930 relying on the permit.

“Honor the permit that was issued,” Momsen said. “If you want to regulate storage containers, by all means, enact some new ordinances to do so, but not after the fact.”

Chuck Vau said city staff had him redraw his plot map to put the containers 5 feet from the property line, not 12 inches, and bring in photos of them before the permit was issued.

“I did everything I was supposed to do,” he said.

Kerri Vau said the containers are for tenants. She said she and her husband own six rental houses on Jackson Avenue, and that tenants pay more than $150 a month for storage elsewhere. She said she asked whether they would pay $50 a month to use the containers.

Momsen’s Nov. 10 letter to the council says the containers are for Vau’s personal storage. Asked about that, he said it was a mistake and that he should have written tenants’ storage.

Kerri Vau said two of the six houses are on the lot with the containers and the others are close by. City Attorney Vaughn said that raised a new question. Whether a building can be “accessory” to homes on other lots, she said, “might be a legal question I need to do more research on.”

What the council said

Marie Villagomez and Dayton gave their names at the podium, and Villagomez read a statement asking the council to deny the appeal.

“We are the ones who see the containers from our window,” she said.

At the meeting Wednesday, Sher, Orozco and Rodin each said the containers aren’t an allowed use in the zone.

“Saying a shipping container is a building is like saying a tent is a hotel room,” Sher said.

Orozco said letting the permit stand would mean the city couldn’t turn down the next applicant. “Pretty soon we’ll have all the west side of the city with containers,” he said.

Crane disagreed Wednesday. He said the permit was issued properly, and that storage is an allowed use.

“Our code speaks to use, not how it’s built, not what it looks like,” Crane said.

Momsen told the council at the start of his remarks that Crane is a current client of his in a commercial lease matter. He said Crane had asked the city attorney whether that was a conflict and was told it wasn’t.

Momsen also asked Sher and Rodin to step aside if they could not be impartial toward Vau. He said Kerri Vau chairs Mendo Matters, a group he said has opposed positions some council members backed. Neither stepped aside.

The council took no formal vote Wednesday. Because it was ruling on an appeal, its decision has to rest on written findings, and Vaughn said she needed until Thursday to draft them.

Momsen said Wednesday that a court would side with the Vaus. “A court would find that, I’m sure,” he said. “We shouldn’t have to go there.”

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *